If you’re rding in your car, just tap the ply button and listen
Introduction: Breaking Free from Tunnel Vision
In cybersecurity, complacency is the enemy. Teams often fall into the trap of “tunnel vision,” relying on familiar scenarios that leave critical gaps in preparedness. But what if an AI could act as a creative partner, pushing responders to think outside the box? Enter flipped interaction—a game-changing approach where generative AI collaborates with humans to build dynamic, multi-layered cybersecurity exercises. This article explores how this method transforms tabletop simulations from stale drills into immersive, adaptive learning experiences.
What Is Flipped Interaction?
Traditional AI prompting involves dictating tasks: “Generate a ransomware scenario.” The result? A generic, one-size-fits-all outline. Flipped interaction flips the script. Instead of commanding the AI, users let the AI guide them through iterative questioning. For example:
- AI: “Who is the tabletop exercise for?”
- User: “Vanderbilt University’s IT, legal, and communications teams.”
- AI: “What type of threat would challenge these groups?”
This dialogue-based method forces participants to consider perspectives they might overlook, such as legal ramifications or public relations crises. By answering one question at a time, the AI adapts its next query based on prior responses, creating a tailored scenario.
Building a Realistic Cybersecurity Tabletop: A Vanderbilt Case Study
Let’s walk through how Vanderbilt University used flipped interaction to design a breach scenario involving research espionage:
Step 1: Setting the Stage
The AI begins by asking foundational questions to establish context:
- “What teams are involved?”
- “What compliance risks matter most?”
Step 2: Injecting Complexity
Instead of prescribing a threat, the user challenges the AI: “Pick a creative, realistic scenario.” The AI responds with a multi-phase attack:
- Phase 1: Suspicious logins from Texas (not overseas) on a faculty account.
- Phase 5: Academic disruption as systems are shut down to contain the breach.
Step 3: Adding Realism
The user enhances details: “The compromised professor complains to the chancellor, creating political pressure.” The AI then expands the scenario to include legal dilemmas and PR challenges.
Result: A cross-functional exercise testing IT’s technical response, legal’s compliance checks, and communications’ crisis management—all woven into a single narrative.
Overcoming AI’s Limits: The Outline Expansion Pattern
Generative AI tools like ChatGPT have token limits (~1 page of text), but the outline expansion pattern solves this. Here’s how:
- Start with a high-level outline: “Phase 1: Unusual logins detected.”
- Drill down iteratively:
- “Expand Phase 1 into 3 decisions the team must make.”
- “Add pros/cons for each decision.”
- Inject granularity:
- “Assume the faculty member is Dr. Jules White, who denies wrongdoing.”
This method builds depth without overwhelming the AI, creating a branching scenario that mirrors real-world complexity.
Interactive Facilitation: AI as Your Co-Pilot
Flipped interaction isn’t just for planning—it can also run tabletops. In one example, the AI role-plays as a facilitator:
- Scenario: A phishing attack triggers ransomware.
- AI: “You’re a professor. What’s your first step?”
- User: “Check if my systems are accessible.”
- AI: “Could logging in spread the ransomware? How else might you verify access?”
This dynamic Q&A exposes blind spots, like the risk of credential exposure during investigations.
Why This Approach Works
- Diverse Perspectives: AI introduces angles humans might miss (e.g., legal or PR fallout).
- Adaptability: Scenarios evolve based on participants’ decisions.
- Efficiency: Teams build detailed exercises faster than manual drafting.
- Realism: Injecting specifics (e.g., disgruntled faculty) adds authenticity.
Best Practices for Implementation
- Avoid Over-Prescription: Let the AI surprise you. Constraints like “test cross-functional teams” work better than rigid scripts.
- Embrace Iteration: Expand scenarios in layers, refining details progressively.
- Use AI as a Thought Partner: If stuck, ask, “What curveball could complicate this phase?”
Conclusion: The Future of Cybersecurity Preparedness
Flipped interaction turns AI from a content generator into a collaborative strategist. By blending human expertise with AI’s adaptability, organizations can craft tabletops that mirror the chaos of real breaches—preparing teams not just to respond, but to outthink adversaries. In an era where threats evolve daily, this fusion of human and machine creativity isn’t just innovative—it’s essential.
Final Thought: The next time you plan a tabletop, don’t just ask AI for answers. Let it ask you the questions—you might be surprised by what you discover.
